⭐⭐⭐⭐Have you ever seen a history documentary where the historian tells you what happened and then there is a reenactment depicting what the historians just spoke about? I love these types of documentaries and strangely that is exactly how this book read. I have never read a book using this approach before but it worked really well. It felt like I was being given a history lesson while reading a very compelling story at the same time.
Mendota and the Restive Rivers of the Indian and Civil Wars 1861-65 follow the fortunes and the misfortunes of the Simmons family. Through their eyes, we witness the horror of the American Civil War and the Dakota Sioux uprising. Dan, the head of the household, is a likeable character. His journey brought home the realities of what life was like during this era in history. Life was hard for a soldier, so terribly hard. With inadequate supplies and a war that seemed neverending, it was miraculous that there was anyone left to fight by the time it was over. Disease ran riot through the ranks, so if a bullet did not get you there was a high chance that dysentery would.
Likewise, Krogman has depicted the desperate situation the Dakota Siouxs' faced. Everything was in short supply—the war ensured that, but for the Dakota Sioux, it meant watching your family starve to death. reading this novel, from a modern perspective, I concluded that the past really is a very foreign county. I find it, even in context, very difficult to understand how anyone could justify starving anyone. The hatred on both sides is evident throughout this novel. When the Sioux finally took matters into their own hands, they targeted a defenceless family. The dilemma that Little Crow faces to defend and try to get justice for his people whilst trying to hold onto his position and keep the respect of his people was written with a great deal of understanding of the situation faced. I thought the depiction of Little Crow was fabulous.
At times this book did make for some very difficult reading—this was, after all, a very brutal time in American history, but I also felt it was a very honest one.
There is a great deal to love about this novel, and I came very close to giving it a full five stars but the editing has really let this book down. There are inconsistencies, not in the writing, but in the editing. There are many instances where the characters all speak in the same paragraph which made it difficult to figure out which voice belonged to whom. I think with a more thorough edit, this book could be something very special indeed.
This is the
fictional story set in Mendota, Minnesota of the Simmons family who are faced
with the consequences of the Dakota Sioux Uprising of 1862 that swept across the
state as well as the Civil War.
The father, Dan
enlists in the 1st regiment of Minnesota volunteers as a teamster. His two
sons, who are both underage join the 2nd Regiment. John, aged 16 becomes a
bugler and William, aged 15 becomes a drummer. Their sister, Sara is left
behind with their mother, Louise to fend for themselves. Dan is sent east to
fight with the Army of the Potomac while his sons are sent to the western
theater to serve in the army of the Cumberland. Back in Mendota, their neighbor
and close friend, Colonel Henry Sibley is ordered to stay in the state to
control the Indian uprising.
Dan will see
action up through the battle of Antietam. He will later find himself in the
hospital in Washington DC where he befriends a comrade also from the 1st
Regiment. His sons barely miss the action at Shiloh but after, are engaged in
all the major battles in the West. While they are passing through Louisville,
William falls for a young woman, Mary who works as a hospital nurse. Back in
Mendota, Sara befriends a young Chippewa native boy while her mother struggles
with the breakup of her family. After Colonel Sibley defeats the Sioux, he is
promoted to General and ordered to round up all the Dakota and push resettle
them in the Dakotas.
This leads to
the punitive expeditions that he and General Sully will command up until 1864.
William is captured at the battle up Missionary Ridge and then sent to the
prison camp at Belle Isle, VA. and then onto Andersonville. GA. John receives a
30 day furlough and returns to Mendota before he re-enlists. Louise and Sara
wait for the war’s end
so the family can be reunited, but events may not turn out as anticipated.
If you would like to read this book then there are several shops where you can purchase the novel. They are as follows:
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Amazon CA
Amazon AU
The Indie BookStore
Dane Pizzuti Krogman was
educated in the fine arts at the University of Minnesota, receiving BFA and MFA
degrees. He also specialized in Asian art history, with a concentration in
textile and surface design. After graduation, he worked as a freelance designer
creating fashion samples for women’s athletic wear. He eventually relocated to
California and taught at Cal-Poly Pomona in the Environmental Design program
then moved on to work as a pictorial artist for outdoor advertising. Moving
back to the Twin Cities in 1981 he formed a scenic design company call Artdemo which
in 10 years did over 1000 designs and productions for sets, props, and special effects
for television commercials and feature films. In the early 90’s he relocated to
Charleston, SC to work as a spec writer for feature film scripts. Six of his
screenplays have won major writing awards and two of these have been optioned
for production. During this time he also taught scene design at the College of
Charleston. This position led to an adjunct teaching position at Virginia
Commonwealth University where he taught art direction for filmmakers. In 1998
he took a full time teaching position at the University of North Carolina
School of the Arts where he taught art direction, life drawing, set
construction, and Asian film studies, eventually becoming chairman of the department.
The common thread through
all of this has been his passion for Japanese design, art, and fashion. He has
lived in Kyoto, Japan for the past 20 summers studying Japanese kimono and obi
design of the Heian and Edo periods. In 2002 he won the Grand Prize for the
best graphic novel at the Hiroshima manga competition. His graphic Novel Skeleton
boy was selected for inclusion into the Hiroshima peace memorial library in 2007.
He was most recently an
adjunct faculty member in the Graduate Program in Digital Filmmaking at Stony
Brook Southampton. He is also an award-winning screenwriter. His screenplay,
The Schooner was produced as the Australian film, AUSTRALIA in 2008. He has other
award-winning films that have been optioned for production or are in production.
As a Civil War historian
he has worked as a technical advisor for the films, Dances with Wolfs,
Gettysburg, and Glory. He currently has one Civil War novel in pre-publication;
MENDOTA, AND THE RESTIVE RIVERS OF THE CIVIL AND INDIAN WARS 1861-65.
He also works part-time as a crew member on a Grand-Am Rolex series race
team. The team won the national championship in 2008
Tour Schedule
